To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Starter set of pliers

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
Here is my $0.02.

Are you going to be working in an industry where you will be using the pliers to make a living? And/Or are tools are hobby/passion and you really appreciate the quality even if just for basic home use?

ITs obvious that you are looking for quality, but if you are looking to save money now and do not need to make a living with them. My advice has always been there is no point in stopping halfway if you want to go to the top. Buy something cheap, the cheap stuff is at every single store so you can play with it all you want to see which cheap ones you like better. Then later on step up to the better ones.

I have never been a fan of Channellocks since I found Knipex Cobra's. Other Channellock products I cannot comment on, they seem okay. However I just don't get why people like the Channellock T&G pliers over the Knipex Cobra's, maybe its because they just think everything they have is the best, or they are a COO USA nut, or maybe they have never tried the Knipex. Maybe I am the one that fell off the deep end, but I had a full set of channellocks and never used them if I could avoid it, I took them to my house and replaced them with Knipex Cobra's. Seems I am always looking for something to use them for and the rest of my pliers sit still.

If you want to invest in good stuff right away, the Cobra's are the one I will say without a doubt get. Go try one if you can find one somewhere. They bite harder, have finer adjustment and are "self-locking" so you only need to put all of your weight into turning them versus trying to hold them closed as well like with T&G's. You probably won't need one over 300mm for most things. I use my huge ones a lot, but a homeowner probably wouldn't.

The pliers wrenches are route to go right away. Skip the crescent wrenches. These will be replacements for crescent wrenches. They are also self locking and can ratchet as well. They are very very nice for many things.

Their cobalt mini bolt cutters are a great addition as well. Personally I prefer the ones with the 20* offset.

Now after that, I will say Knipex, NWS, and many of the other foreign brands are awesome, but if you wish to stay USA I will not knock you. It is up to you then. You really just need a linemans pliers, and a couple good needle noses.

I will have to admit I am a bit of a Knipex junkie as illustrated in the picture below, but my post above is as non-biased as I can be on the pliers topic.

Perhaps this is not the place for a political discussion (besides I am just a know nothing high school student) but the quality is not the only thing that draws me to USA tools, it's the theory that the way for us to boost the economy is to buy USA. After all it is someones job and business to make the tool that you are using so if they are passed over they hurt and so does the economy. I'm not talking about 'the good ol' days, I am to young to know about them. Just my two cents.

Its good to support your neighbor, but with the way things are, I can't bring myself to it. Maybe its just me but I think more than half of the people I meet on the streets or out and about are a*holes that I wouldn't want to support anyways. Maybe I am the a hole I dont know.

I feel with tools, its a business decision when they are your money makers. You have to put you and your families needs first. For me that involves buying the best products needed. The US sadly has slipped very very far down that tube. They stopped innovating a long time ago and use the made in USA COO as a marketing tool more often than a quality mark.

I'll not disagree that many American manufacturers could take a quality control lesson from the Germans, but explain to me how this applies to Channellock? They've been around for a century, the make the most durable pliers on the market, they're committed to the American worker, and the do it all at a surprisingly low price that isn't much more than a lot of the Chinese junk floating around. For the quality you get, there isn't a better USA made value on the market.

Not to all of their pliers, but when it comes to water pump style pliers, I don't get it. Should I post a video up of the quality of the Channellocks I have versus my Knipex? They channellocks are very sloppy and do not work well at all. They are only a couple years old and I rarely used them.

In my picture below I have two channellock pliers. They are useless. I try to use them but they do not work well at all, way too much flex in them.

They may be the best USA made tool, but that doesn't say much in my opinion anymore. Made in USA is a marketing too for all I care, certainly isn't for labeling the best in quality and innovation anymore.

I have to disagree that they do the job just as well. The knipex cobra, you can apply way more clamping force then a pair of tongue and groove plier design. Also you can lock them down on a pipe with just down force on the back handle to rotate the pipe, something that is impossible with a tongue and groove design where you need to have pressure on both handle to have the teeth bite.

x2

because you are going up against the COO mofia on GJ.

I notice that hear almost more than on farming boards. Made in USA just isn't what it was 80 years ago but many can't seem to move on.

good for you! just remember, supporting your american mfg's when you can is a good thing.

When you can, sure. However, you have to do what is financially responsible and best for what you need to do. You are a farmer, so you should be able to relate to this.

I have given up on Made in USA. They just can't seem to figure it out. We have dealt with Agco, CNH and Deere and Fendt is just too far ahead to look back. Yes Agco owns them but they do nothing other than own them and use their transmissions. Fendt is very much their own company still. The americans are just too far behind. Germans win again.

Same goes for Choppers and Combines. We had a Deere SPFH. It was terrible, service was even worse. Our Claas has been excellent with far better service to back it up, they aren't even an American company and have better service. Damn Germans, guess they are too good at what they do.

BTW when we bought our Deere we supported the Germans as well as they are built in germany.

Our manure tanker is Canadian, owned by a German company now though. The US built ones just didn't cut it for what we needed.

We all like our VW/Audi vehicles much more than our American made pickups, but we need pickups and really like the Duramax so we support Americans there.

All of our tires (except for pickup tires) are Michelin. Many are made in the USA, but we are supporting a French company. Goodyear/Titan are really the true American tire companies and look how sad their products are. You being in ag I would assume you have seen how terrible their tires are on farm equipment.

Metabo, Bosch, Fein, Flex, Festool.......the list goes on and on for German companies that just seem to excel.

So what are some good European brands for screw drivers?

You just had to ask didn't you. My personal favorite is Wiha. I have been upgrading my old stuff to theirs as well as adding some of their more interesting drivers. I ordered a Felo, Wiha and Wera of the identical same sizes and tested them all to see which one felt the best for me. Wiha did. I like the big handle and Microfinish. I had CMan pros. Some of the Wiha's were actually cheaper than the Cmans. The Cmans gave me a lot of troubles so I retired them to my house, others seem to like them a lot though.


Pictures are worth a thousand words. Did I mention I like Knipex a little? Careful, the German tool bug bites hard.

20130318_221835_zps9ac98461.jpg


Here are some Wiha's. The purple ones are microfinish HD Phillips/slotted. The Yellow and Red ones are Softfinish nut drivers.

20130316_133209_zps9cf8126a.jpg


20130316_133341_zpsd7e8c334.jpg
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

jtw401

Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
22
Location
eastern North Carolina
also as far as pliers go...Knipex is very superior...Klein is a good brand when it comes to wire strippers (although they arent what they used to be)...Channel-Lock is a great brand as well, i use their needle nose all the time, they're very "needly" and fit into tight spots w/ strength...for vise-grips, go name-brand....
Also, what is everyone's thoughts on Snap-On pliers? I like Snap-on but their pliers ****! Their crimper/cutter is a joke compared to channel-lock, their needle nose wont fit on anything because they're too big, and other than their "talon grip" combo pliers, they might wanna just stay out of the pliers game...
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
also as far as pliers go...Knipex is very superior...Klein is a good brand when it comes to wire strippers (although they arent what they used to be)...Channel-Lock is a great brand as well, i use their needle nose all the time, they're very "needly" and fit into tight spots w/ strength...for vise-grips, go name-brand....
Also, what is everyone's thoughts on Snap-On pliers? I like Snap-on but their pliers ****! Their crimper/cutter is a joke compared to channel-lock, their needle nose wont fit on anything because they're too big, and other than their "talon grip" combo pliers, they might wanna just stay out of the pliers game...

I buy snap on because I like shiny chrome wrenches and sockets. I also like big huge heavy toolboxes. After I get my shiny fix, I go elseware.
 

Brownsfan

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2012
Messages
5,975
Location
Cleveland Ohio
So what are some good European brands for screw drivers?

I like Witte. They make the screwdrivers for Matco and Cornwell. I have a Cornwell set and they are great screwdrivers. My road set is Williams(snap on hard handle clones) and I am liking them more than the Cornwells at this point. They replaced my Craftsman Pros that I gave to my nephew for his starter set. For just under 55 bucks you can get a great set for the money I bought the 6pc slotted and phillips. Yea it was a little over kill but who cares they get used and serve their purpose. http://www.amazon.com/s/?ie=UTF8&ke...vpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=b&ref=pd_sl_8il5kgi57h_b
 
OP
H

hallboyone

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 26, 2013
Messages
129
Location
North Carolina
I am confused...in your original post you wanted USA pliers, and now you want European screwdrivers? Huh?:dunno:
I would love to get American made tools but I may be willing to slip with a set of screw drivers. Nothing infuriates me more than a screw driver breaking so I am more willing to get the best that I can get even if it means buying European. Hey, at least it isn't made in china, I would rather my money end up in Europe than in China!
 

Conductor562

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,312
Location
West "By God" Virginia
durallymax, you're obviously into German tools and that's all fine and good, but Channellocks are useless? Are you f$&king serious? :lol_hitti
They haven't been in business for almost 130 years by selling useless ****. I love the comment that insinuates most Americans aren't worth supporting. Good for you pal.
 

eddie1278

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
344
I use my channellocks almost on a daily basis in the electrical trade. The people who are hating on them just have an axe to grind. There is absolutely nothing wrong with them and a high quality product. That's why they are trusted by most professionals.

You don't stay in business for 125 years by making junk. This Knipex bandwagon jumping has all started roughly in the past 5 years I noticed.

All the hype for knipex and I went and bought a pair of dykes they are nothing compared to my Kleins.
 

Brownsfan

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2012
Messages
5,975
Location
Cleveland Ohio
I would love to get American made tools but I may be willing to slip with a set of screw drivers. Nothing infuriates me more than a screw driver breaking so I am more willing to get the best that I can get even if it means buying European. Hey, at least it isn't made in china, I would rather my money end up in Europe than in China!

Look at the williams set I linked in my post above. I own a set of German witte drivers labeled Cornwell and I really like the Williams better. For the price they are a GREAT value and GREAT qualitly that will last
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,564
Location
nd
durallymax, you're obviously into German tools and that's all fine and good, but Channellocks are useless? Are you f$&king serious? :lol_hitti
They haven't been in business for almost 130 years by selling useless ****. I love the comment that insinuates most Americans aren't worth supporting. Good for you pal.
yup, quite a comment.:willy_nil


he must be pals with shoturtle. some comments that people make aren't worth the time to respond to.:eyecrazy:
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,564
Location
nd
durallymax, you're obviously into German tools and that's all fine and good, but Channellocks are useless? Are you f$&king serious? :lol_hitti
They haven't been in business for almost 130 years by selling useless ****. I love the comment that insinuates most Americans aren't worth supporting. Good for you pal.
yup, quite a comment.:willy_nil


he must be pals with shoturtle. some comments that people make aren't worth the time to respond to.:eyecrazy:

i mean really, the kid wants a couple pairs of pliers and unless he spends his whole lifetime allowance money on a drawer full of german hardware he may as well just get some 99 center's at the dollar store. i think the jackboot germans is a better description than the coo mofia. (his spelling, not mine).:lol_hitti
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
durallymax, you're obviously into German tools and that's all fine and good, but Channellocks are useless? Are you f$&king serious? :lol_hitti
They haven't been in business for almost 130 years by selling useless ****. I love the comment that insinuates most Americans aren't worth supporting. Good for you pal.

You need to re-read my post. I was referring to the two specific long reach channel locks pliers that I have. Short of using them to fish something out of an engine valley that I dropped they are useless.

I am not saying all channellocks are useless and reccommended them to some.

You don't stay in business for 125 years by making junk. This Knipex bandwagon jumping has all started roughly in the past 5 years I noticed.

All the hype for knipex and I went and bought a pair of dykes they are nothing compared to my Kleins.

I am glad they have been in business since 1886. Knipex has been in business since 1882. Guess that makes them better by you twos standards?

Most American companies are very old, too many have fallen back on their "heritage" and stopped the innovation.

When it comes to Knipex Cobra's, Plierswrenches and their precisions snap ring pliers, I'll fight to the death that they are great. Everything else, pick your pleasure doesn;t matter to me, I buy the Knipex then because I like them but other brands work just fine, those three things though I will argue that others cannot compete.

The reason the hype is just forming is because they are newer and gaining popularity. More and more people are loosing faith in the Made in USA and going to better foreign brands.

Fendt has been in the US since 2002. Already they have dominated many markets where they have dealer support. Sure there are more John Deeres out there, but it has nothing to do with who was great 130 years ago, what matters is who is good now.
 
Last edited:

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
yup, quite a comment.:willy_nil


he must be pals with shoturtle. some comments that people make aren't worth the time to respond to.:eyecrazy:

i mean really, the kid wants a couple pairs of pliers and unless he spends his whole lifetime allowance money on a drawer full of german hardware he may as well just get some 99 center's at the dollar store. i think the jackboot germans is a better description than the coo mofia. (his spelling, not mine).:lol_hitti

Again you need to re-read my post. It was strictly relating to the two that are in my picture above. Those two are useless to me for the type of work I do.

I do not know shoturtle at all and rarely get on here.

He doesn't need to spend his money on Knipex. What I am saying is that if you think the Cobras would be better for you than the Channellocks then why spend the money on channellocks at first. Get something that will last you until you can afford the ones you want. Lets say cheap is $10. Channellocks is $30 and Knipex is $60. Why spend $90 when you can spend $70.

Now if he doesn't want the cobras or does not feel they are better for his needs, then by all means buy the channellocks.

I also never said he needed a full drawer. I said a cobalt cutter, and two cobras the he can add pliers wrenches as needed. Just because my drawer has a lot doesnt mean I am telling him to buy a lot. Again something I explained in my post but apparently not clear enough for the ruthless channellock crowd.

You guys are fishing for something that isn't there. Maybe I need to be more clear in my comments.
 
Last edited:

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,564
Location
nd
i have a fendt dealer down the road, they can't sell the damn things. neighbor had one, hated it and couldn't wait for the lease to be up. the first one in this area was here long before 2002. claas combines? good combines if you can get parts and then if you can afford to fix them. i have three dealers within 50 miles of me, used to be quite a few claas combines. after people ran 1 or 2 and they started to have to fix them they went back to the other brands
 

cburnscrx

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,751
Location
Indianapolis
I would love to get American made tools but I may be willing to slip with a set of screw drivers. Nothing infuriates me more than a screw driver breaking so I am more willing to get the best that I can get even if it means buying European. Hey, at least it isn't made in china, I would rather my money end up in Europe than in China!

If you're looking for USA screwdrivers, get the Craftsman Professionals...if you're worried about warranty and the Craftsman Pro's being discontinued, then get the SK version. They're USA made too. There are a whole lot of people on here who like the Craftsman Professionals...they're made by SK.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0096PFTEW/?tag=atomicindus08-20

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-prof...ckType=G14&PDP_REDIRECT=false&s_tnt=39869:4:0
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
i have a fendt dealer down the road, they can't sell the damn things. neighbor had one, hated it and couldn't wait for the lease to be up. the first one in this area was here long before 2002. claas combines? good combines if you can get parts and then if you can afford to fix them. i have three dealers within 50 miles of me, used to be quite a few claas combines. after people ran 1 or 2 and they started to have to fix them they went back to the other brands

Service is the Issue. With Agco backing them it can be tough. There are also people who just dont like them. There is a lot of technology in them that some do not want or need.

For a dirt farmer they may not be as popular, for us where high speed transport is needed for forage and manure, they cannot be beat. The local dealer lost their other brand due to the high volume of sales.

what wrre the reasons for people hating them? The early ones were not as great, the MAN motor also had a few more issues The new series with X5 Profi cabs and Duetz motors are much nicer.

Claas would see more combines around here if the dealer support was better. Aside from the all John Deere farms though they dominate the forage harvester market here

Sales of equipment come down to service and if the person is instructed properly on how to operate the new technology. When referencing technology, quality and innovation, sales numbers have less to do with it. Theres more technology in a Mercedes but they sure sell less than Ford or GM.
 

Conductor562

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,312
Location
West "By God" Virginia
Its good to support your neighbor, but with the way things are, I can't bring myself to it. Maybe its just me but I think more than half of the people I meet on the streets or out and about are a*holes that I wouldn't want to support anyways. Maybe I am the a hole I dont know.

This statement is as far as I needed to read. If you like German tools thats great. They make quality stuff and I'll not fault anyone for being partial to it. But writing off over half of your fellow countrymen as assholes who aren't worth supporting? I'm not even going to get into all the reasons that statement pisses me off, but rest assured that it does. Many American manufacturers could take a lesson from Channellock. They produce a very durable, high quality, tool in America and sell it for an affordable price. There are American manufacturers skating by on a reputation of quality gained long ago and no longer deserved, but Channellock is not one of them. To me America is worth supporting. From the quoted statement it's apparent you don't think so.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

ddo

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 29, 2012
Messages
153
Location
Richland
German, taiwanese and chinese jobs are every bit as importand as american jobs. Im all for american jobs but not at the expense of all others.

People complain about the chinese being able to manufacture so cheaply and that they only pay there workers 15 cents or whatever it is but neglect to think that the prices are cheap because people are desperate for work in a competitive environment. Maybe they need the jobs more than we do and thats why theyre willing to do them for cheap.

I aint saying that out of a lack of patriotism or hate for america. Im saying it because i for one realize that america is not "special" and doesnt have to win all the time every time.
 

Conductor562

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,312
Location
West "By God" Virginia
German, taiwanese and chinese jobs are every bit as importand as american jobs. Im all for american jobs but not at the expense of all others.

People complain about the chinese being able to manufacture so cheaply and that they only pay there workers 15 cents or whatever it is but neglect to think that the prices are cheap because people are desperate for work in a competitive environment. Maybe they need the jobs more than we do and thats why theyre willing to do them for cheap.

I aint saying that out of a lack of patriotism or hate for america. Im saying it because i for one realize that america is not "special" and doesnt have to win all the time every time.

Look around you pal, Americans are kind of in need of work themselves. Comments like yours are proof that there is no hope for us. You're essentially saying you support foreign nations ahead of your own (by choice) and feel you're doing a noble thing in doing so. Jobs in other countries are great, but you need to take care of your own first. You wouldn't give your paychecks to your neighbor and raise your kids in a tent, so why would you give your money to China when you're own countrymen are hurting for jobs to take care of their families? This thread has really opened my eyes to just how screwed up people are capable of being.
 

vintagefan

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 2, 2012
Messages
613
USA made is a nice sentiment to have but I don't buy into it. The problem with America is the participation trophy mindset and in reality, if American industry wants to save itself they need to start doing it best rather than relying on sentiment of the good old days.

There are some quite superb quality american pliers other than channellock.

Wilde, for one. Then you have Swanstrom for precision cutters/pliers, Midwest shears/snips, Heritage/Klein scissors, (some of) Klein's pliers are pretty much as good as it gets. Snap-on has a couple of exclusives that are literally one-of-a-kind (47CF, PWCS7, a few others).

I use Knipex and some other COO brands as well, but over many years of trial and error, I find that at least half of my tools are USA made because those specific tools are the very best design/quality/ergonomics/price in the industry for my needs.

If you're curious, I'd be happy to go into specifics on particular models, why I feel they're the best, what makes them unique, etc.

Look around you pal, Americans are kind of in need of work themselves. Comments like yours are proof that there is no hope for us. You're essentially saying you support foreign nations ahead of your own (by choice) and feel you're doing a noble thing in doing so. Jobs in other countries are great, but you need to take care of your own first. You wouldn't give your paychecks to your neighbor and raise your kids in a tent, so why would you give your money to China when you're own countrymen are hurting for jobs to take care of their families? This thread has really opened my eyes to just how screwed up people are capable of being.

I believe the saying is "Don't **** on your own dinner plate".
 

rick carpenter

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
3,786
Location
Huntsville, East Texas
Gagreen and Slowpoke have some good advice. As for my advice, there's nothing wrong with buying quality used tools at garage sales or flea markets. If the pliers joint isn't sloppy and the teeth somewhat sharp, they'll do you some good. Plus, you'll be able to do a little hands-on comparison of brands and styles.

After you get your starter set of pliers, consider at some point nutbusters. I don't need mine often, but when I do I do. They grip somewhat like a pipewrench. I'm not sure what brand I have, as they are old and have a lot of character/patina/stain/grime/love on them, but Channellock makes new ones. My next new pliers will be Channellocks.
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
This statement is as far as I needed to read. If you like German tools thats great. They make quality stuff and I'll not fault anyone for being partial to it. But writing off over half of your fellow countrymen as assholes who aren't worth supporting? I'm not even going to get into all the reasons that statement pisses me off, but rest assured that it does. Many American manufacturers could take a lesson from Channellock. They produce a very durable, high quality, tool in America and sell it for an affordable price. There are American manufacturers skating by on a reputation of quality gained long ago and no longer deserved, but Channellock is not one of them. To me America is worth supporting. From the quoted statement it's apparent you don't think so.

I am sorry that I offended you, and yes I cam off harsh. It is very obvious how patriotic you are and I applaud you for being able to remain that way.

When someone asks for a tool recommendation I just give the tool that's best for the job regardless of where it came from, in this post I overstepped my usual boundaries and brought politics into it. I don't like to do that. Its a worse battle than which pliers are better.

Since I cannot undo what I said, the least I could do is explain where I come from on my point.

We have a large dairy farm.We have tried numerous times to hire American workers. It is impossible, we quit hiring them or even trying. For starters nobody would take the job because they felt "entitled" to more. The ones who did take the job shortly after grew the same attitude or became unreliable. We have had little to no success with any American worker unless they were straight off their families farm. Due to this our labor is not American. What they are is reliable, honest good workers that want to work. I don't care what country you come from. The guy who does the best job at the end of the day gets the job. I am not going to favor the American because he is American. Same thing goes for tools. I want the best for the job. For me its either a tool that needs to last a longtime, or needs to last long enough until someone looses it. American made does not fit too many of those categories but I would say over half of my toolbox is American made.

Why do I think so many people are the way they are? I dk. They bother me all day and try to run our farms. We are just outside of a very liberal town who thinks we all need to be organic all natural farms with raw milk. Now that is generalizing but if you lived here you would see the reality. The other half of that is all of the people I encounter who just do not want to work. Like I said, we have tried giving them jobs but it does not work. You cannot turn a blind eye because they are white. You have to be equal.

My final issue is the American way. Find ways to get rich by doing nothing. Every tour a German factory? Half of the people don't even have safety glasses. There are not warning posters everywhere for every little thing. They do not have the factories idiot proofed so far that to protect themselves against lawyers because they do not have the negligence laws like we do here. Do you know what they use for transportation inside the Claas factory? Bicycles. With no helmets either, that would get an American lawyer drooling. But over there, if you put your hand on a glowing red piece of metal, you cant sue them, you are just an idiot, you should know better or you should not be playing with machines and equipment you do not understand. There is a lot more respect there than here.

I am sure channellock is a great company. They seem to be, some of their products I do not care for but many I do like. For an American brand they do a good job.

Look at this from another angle, innovation. Lets look at the American companies. Where is their innovation in the tools themselves? Its not there anymore, they are selling on a name and a tool that was ahead of its time years ago. They still may be quality but many are just riding the waves. Why? Simple, people pay them because they feel the need to support their country. If you continue to pay them, they will continue to see no need to innovate and be competitive. If they start loosing profits due to other tools working better, they will start the innovation machine back up again.

Its just the overall American way I don't care for some day. Its only my opinion, but I feel the American way is to use ideas from others and find a way to mass produce cheaper with decent quality.

Go into a grade school, middle school, heck even high school and ask the kids who invented the automobile and the assembly line. I bet the majority will tell you Henry Ford. He invented neither of these. He was a genius in his own way, he found a way to use others ideas and streamline them to make something simple of decent quality that was cheap and had a high profit margin. His cars were not innovative, nor was the assembly line, but the way he planned everything out and made it a success is why he is famous, yet our school books lead us to believe Americans invented everything and too many people never learn the real truth.

Ask them about the tires on that car and many say Harvey Firestone. He basically knew Ford and had an "in". Another form of the American way, knowing the right people, getting in their pockets. Henry Ford didn't necessarily choose Harveys tire because it was the best.

Why are the American tire companies Foreign owned (besides goodyear)? Because they were too stubborn and resistant to change. After Michelin invented the radial tire, the Americans refused it like it was the plague because it would cost them too much of their money. BFGoodrich tried making a radial but was shunned by the industry. They are now owned by Michelin. Firestone scrambled and was still focused on their own pocketbooks that they tried to cheat and make radials on Bias machines. Everyone knows how that turned out. The Formula tire. Shortly after, Firestone was bought up by Bridgestone. Uniroyal is also owned by Michelin.

Go ask Daimler which trucks run better, the ones made in North Carolina by UAW workers or the ones made in Mexico? Mexico. They have stated it, their problem trucks come from NC, the ones without gremlins come from Mexico. Why? Because, if you don't do a good job down there you are fired and you do not get a handout.

I guess I am not very patriotic( well in a way, My ancestors are all German) and I apologize. I am focused on finding the best products to do the jobs I need to do. I will not turn a blind eye because something says made in the USA. I would rather spend my money encouraging progress and innovation, versus living in the past. We all need progress and change don't we? Isn't that what everything is about?

Thats all I really have to say on this topic, I do not want to derail too much. However I hope you have a better understanding of where my viewpoint on the Made in USA topic comes from.

I do wish you take some time and respond to some of my response to your claims, you seem very on edge about this issue and I like a friendly debate. Can't learn anything without trying.
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
Look around you pal, Americans are kind of in need of work themselves. Comments like yours are proof that there is no hope for us. You're essentially saying you support foreign nations ahead of your own (by choice) and feel you're doing a noble thing in doing so. Jobs in other countries are great, but you need to take care of your own first. You wouldn't give your paychecks to your neighbor and raise your kids in a tent, so why would you give your money to China when you're own countrymen are hurting for jobs to take care of their families? This thread has really opened my eyes to just how screwed up people are capable of being.

Americans are in need of work but do not want to work. I explained this in my other post. We have offered jobs to them left and right and they do not want them.

I'll gladly support a company like Germany, they are bailing out the rest of the EU. Maybe USA will realize socialism doesn't work.

If my neighbor built a better product I would give him my money instead of foreign countries.

What sad is that the Foreign companies produce more patriotic goods than American companies. Isn't the Mustang the least American made car and some Toyota the most American made? Kind of ironic eh? VW and Toyota dominate the auto world, the big 3 are falling very far behind.

How are we screwed up? Because we don't turn a blind eye to everything bad in America because its America? I don't get into politics of things. I support what is the best product, if it isn't made here, then fine chalk it up as another loss to America, maybe someday they will wake up and smell the roses and start innovating and making good products. We could help give them the funds by shipping empty containers back to China filled with lawyers if you would like?
 

abvw

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 9, 2012
Messages
645
Location
Toronto, Canada
I am sorry that I offended you, and yes I cam off harsh. It is very obvious how patriotic you are and I applaud you for being able to remain that way.

When someone asks for a tool recommendation I just give the tool that's best for the job regardless of where it came from, in this post I overstepped my usual boundaries and brought politics into it. I don't like to do that. Its a worse battle than which pliers are better.

Since I cannot undo what I said, the least I could do is explain where I come from on my point.

We have a large dairy farm.We have tried numerous times to hire American workers. It is impossible, we quit hiring them or even trying. For starters nobody would take the job because they felt "entitled" to more. The ones who did take the job shortly after grew the same attitude or became unreliable. We have had little to no success with any American worker unless they were straight off their families farm. Due to this our labor is not American. What they are is reliable, honest good workers that want to work. I don't care what country you come from. The guy who does the best job at the end of the day gets the job. I am not going to favor the American because he is American. Same thing goes for tools. I want the best for the job. For me its either a tool that needs to last a longtime, or needs to last long enough until someone looses it. American made does not fit too many of those categories but I would say over half of my toolbox is American made.

Why do I think so many people are the way they are? I dk. They bother me all day and try to run our farms. We are just outside of a very liberal town who thinks we all need to be organic all natural farms with raw milk. Now that is generalizing but if you lived here you would see the reality. The other half of that is all of the people I encounter who just do not want to work. Like I said, we have tried giving them jobs but it does not work. You cannot turn a blind eye because they are white. You have to be equal.

My final issue is the American way. Find ways to get rich by doing nothing. Every tour a German factory? Half of the people don't even have safety glasses. There are not warning posters everywhere for every little thing. They do not have the factories idiot proofed so far that to protect themselves against lawyers because they do not have the negligence laws like we do here. Do you know what they use for transportation inside the Claas factory? Bicycles. With no helmets either, that would get an American lawyer drooling. But over there, if you put your hand on a glowing red piece of metal, you cant sue them, you are just an idiot, you should know better or you should not be playing with machines and equipment you do not understand. There is a lot more respect there than here.

I am sure channellock is a great company. They seem to be, some of their products I do not care for but many I do like. For an American brand they do a good job.

Look at this from another angle, innovation. Lets look at the American companies. Where is their innovation in the tools themselves? Its not there anymore, they are selling on a name and a tool that was ahead of its time years ago. They still may be quality but many are just riding the waves. Why? Simple, people pay them because they feel the need to support their country. If you continue to pay them, they will continue to see no need to innovate and be competitive. If they start loosing profits due to other tools working better, they will start the innovation machine back up again.

Its just the overall American way I don't care for some day. Its only my opinion, but I feel the American way is to use ideas from others and find a way to mass produce cheaper with decent quality.

Go into a grade school, middle school, heck even high school and ask the kids who invented the automobile and the assembly line. I bet the majority will tell you Henry Ford. He invented neither of these. He was a genius in his own way, he found a way to use others ideas and streamline them to make something simple of decent quality that was cheap and had a high profit margin. His cars were not innovative, nor was the assembly line, but the way he planned everything out and made it a success is why he is famous, yet our school books lead us to believe Americans invented everything and too many people never learn the real truth.

Ask them about the tires on that car and many say Harvey Firestone. He basically knew Ford and had an "in". Another form of the American way, knowing the right people, getting in their pockets. Henry Ford didn't necessarily choose Harveys tire because it was the best.

Why are the American tire companies Foreign owned (besides goodyear)? Because they were too stubborn and resistant to change. After Michelin invented the radial tire, the Americans refused it like it was the plague because it would cost them too much of their money. BFGoodrich tried making a radial but was shunned by the industry. They are now owned by Michelin. Firestone scrambled and was still focused on their own pocketbooks that they tried to cheat and make radials on Bias machines. Everyone knows how that turned out. The Formula tire. Shortly after, Firestone was bought up by Bridgestone. Uniroyal is also owned by Michelin.

Go ask Daimler which trucks run better, the ones made in North Carolina by UAW workers or the ones made in Mexico? Mexico. They have stated it, their problem trucks come from NC, the ones without gremlins come from Mexico. Why? Because, if you don't do a good job down there you are fired and you do not get a handout.

I guess I am not very patriotic( well in a way, My ancestors are all German) and I apologize. I am focused on finding the best products to do the jobs I need to do. I will not turn a blind eye because something says made in the USA. I would rather spend my money encouraging progress and innovation, versus living in the past. We all need progress and change don't we? Isn't that what everything is about?

Thats all I really have to say on this topic, I do not want to derail too much. However I hope you have a better understanding of where my viewpoint on the Made in USA topic comes from.

I do wish you take some time and respond to some of my response to your claims, you seem very on edge about this issue and I like a friendly debate. Can't learn anything without trying.

Boom, headshot!
 

ddo

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 29, 2012
Messages
153
Location
Richland
I buy a ton of us products. I buy snap on, i buy channellock, i buy wilde, etc. Some are better. I prefer my channellock linesmans to my knipex linesmans. I by no means buy preferentially foreign.

The point i was getting at in my posts in this thread is that if there is a foreign product that is better you should not be made out as the antichrist for buying them. Market demand drives industry. There are some great products out there that are stealing market share from american companies. This just means that american companies need to offer products to compete on same level. Some american tools are best. Not all are. On the ones that arent, they need to change, not to be bailed out.

In my last post the point was people in foreign countries are people too. Many of them participate in this forum as well. Dont read something into it that wasnt there. Chinese people dont live great. We live infinitely better in america and that was my point. Just because theyre used to living in tents doesnt make it better.

My only issue with channellock has only ever been that i wished they would modernize their adjustment mechanism like knipex, irwin, dewalt, nws, facom and many other brands have done. I would love to buy a pair from channellock if they would.
 

Conductor562

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,312
Location
West "By God" Virginia
@ durallymax: I do understand what you're saying and there is a lot of truth in it, but I'm not willing to write America off because of it. I support American manufacturers because I want to see us maintain what little manufacturing base we have left. Without getting political, we probably agree on more things than you probably think, but if there is an American product that suits my needs, I'm giving it first look. Sure I occasionally buy a Taiwan or China made tool and I don't feel bad about it, but I'm not going to even attempt to take a position that they are anywhere near the level of quality as the Proto tools that make up 70% of the tools I own. Most German tools are great quality, but I still believe most American tools are as well.
 

eddie1278

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
344
I am sorry that I offended you, and yes I cam off harsh. It is very obvious how patriotic you are and I applaud you for being able to remain that way.

When someone asks for a tool recommendation I just give the tool that's best for the job regardless of where it came from, in this post I overstepped my usual boundaries and brought politics into it. I don't like to do that. Its a worse battle than which pliers are better.

Since I cannot undo what I said, the least I could do is explain where I come from on my point.

We have a large dairy farm.We have tried numerous times to hire American workers. It is impossible, we quit hiring them or even trying. For starters nobody would take the job because they felt "entitled" to more. The ones who did take the job shortly after grew the same attitude or became unreliable. We have had little to no success with any American worker unless they were straight off their families farm. Due to this our labor is not American. What they are is reliable, honest good workers that want to work. I don't care what country you come from. The guy who does the best job at the end of the day gets the job. I am not going to favor the American because he is American. Same thing goes for tools. I want the best for the job. For me its either a tool that needs to last a longtime, or needs to last long enough until someone looses it. American made does not fit too many of those categories but I would say over half of my toolbox is American made.

Why do I think so many people are the way they are? I dk. They bother me all day and try to run our farms. We are just outside of a very liberal town who thinks we all need to be organic all natural farms with raw milk. Now that is generalizing but if you lived here you would see the reality. The other half of that is all of the people I encounter who just do not want to work. Like I said, we have tried giving them jobs but it does not work. You cannot turn a blind eye because they are white. You have to be equal.

My final issue is the American way. Find ways to get rich by doing nothing. Every tour a German factory? Half of the people don't even have safety glasses. There are not warning posters everywhere for every little thing. They do not have the factories idiot proofed so far that to protect themselves against lawyers because they do not have the negligence laws like we do here. Do you know what they use for transportation inside the Claas factory? Bicycles. With no helmets either, that would get an American lawyer drooling. But over there, if you put your hand on a glowing red piece of metal, you cant sue them, you are just an idiot, you should know better or you should not be playing with machines and equipment you do not understand. There is a lot more respect there than here.

I am sure channellock is a great company. They seem to be, some of their products I do not care for but many I do like. For an American brand they do a good job.

Look at this from another angle, innovation. Lets look at the American companies. Where is their innovation in the tools themselves? Its not there anymore, they are selling on a name and a tool that was ahead of its time years ago. They still may be quality but many are just riding the waves. Why? Simple, people pay them because they feel the need to support their country. If you continue to pay them, they will continue to see no need to innovate and be competitive. If they start loosing profits due to other tools working better, they will start the innovation machine back up again.

Its just the overall American way I don't care for some day. Its only my opinion, but I feel the American way is to use ideas from others and find a way to mass produce cheaper with decent quality.

Go into a grade school, middle school, heck even high school and ask the kids who invented the automobile and the assembly line. I bet the majority will tell you Henry Ford. He invented neither of these. He was a genius in his own way, he found a way to use others ideas and streamline them to make something simple of decent quality that was cheap and had a high profit margin. His cars were not innovative, nor was the assembly line, but the way he planned everything out and made it a success is why he is famous, yet our school books lead us to believe Americans invented everything and too many people never learn the real truth.

Ask them about the tires on that car and many say Harvey Firestone. He basically knew Ford and had an "in". Another form of the American way, knowing the right people, getting in their pockets. Henry Ford didn't necessarily choose Harveys tire because it was the best.

Why are the American tire companies Foreign owned (besides goodyear)? Because they were too stubborn and resistant to change. After Michelin invented the radial tire, the Americans refused it like it was the plague because it would cost them too much of their money. BFGoodrich tried making a radial but was shunned by the industry. They are now owned by Michelin. Firestone scrambled and was still focused on their own pocketbooks that they tried to cheat and make radials on Bias machines. Everyone knows how that turned out. The Formula tire. Shortly after, Firestone was bought up by Bridgestone. Uniroyal is also owned by Michelin.

Go ask Daimler which trucks run better, the ones made in North Carolina by UAW workers or the ones made in Mexico? Mexico. They have stated it, their problem trucks come from NC, the ones without gremlins come from Mexico. Why? Because, if you don't do a good job down there you are fired and you do not get a handout.

I guess I am not very patriotic( well in a way, My ancestors are all German) and I apologize. I am focused on finding the best products to do the jobs I need to do. I will not turn a blind eye because something says made in the USA. I would rather spend my money encouraging progress and innovation, versus living in the past. We all need progress and change don't we? Isn't that what everything is about?

Thats all I really have to say on this topic, I do not want to derail too much. However I hope you have a better understanding of where my viewpoint on the Made in USA topic comes from.

I do wish you take some time and respond to some of my response to your claims, you seem very on edge about this issue and I like a friendly debate. Can't learn anything without trying.

You could always move to another country....

just sayin
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
@ durallymax: I do understand what you're saying and there is a lot of truth in it, but I'm not willing to write America off because of it. I support American manufacturers because I want to see us maintain what little manufacturing base we have left. Without getting political, we probably agree on more things than you probably think, but if there is an American product that suits my needs, I'm giving it first look. Sure I occasionally buy a Taiwan or China made tool and I don't feel bad about it, but I'm not going to even attempt to take a position that they are anywhere near the level of quality as the Proto tools that make up 70% of the tools I own. Most German tools are great quality, but I still believe most American tools are as well.

I think you are right. We do agree on many things. You seem to have a similar outlook, just lean towards supporting the Americans while I lean the other way. Similar outlook, different end results. Makes me happy enough. Now I don't just think your some blinded by the Made in USA sticker person, and I hope you see I am not any worse with the German sticker.

The one thing we don't agree on still is where to put the money. I don't know which one of us does it right, however I do not believe in giving money away to make things better. If the American companies would start loosing marketshare they might wakeup and do a much better job, then the German companies will be swimming in their money and America might sneak up on them with better products and the cycle may repeat.

I haven't given up on the US, just don't agree with a lot of the stuff. I remember being much simpler when I was a kid, maybe it was because I didn't know any better, but it sure seemed like we were more on top then.

Guten Tag


You could always move to another country....

just sayin

Thank's, I have considered it but have no reason to. There's many thing I don't like here and just as many things I do not like there. Kind of hard to just leave a business too.
 
Last edited:

ChevyEFI

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
8,766
Location
Phoenix, AZ
I'm not looking to have every tool by the age of twenty or whatever, all I want is to start building a set that will last a lifetime (made in the US of A)
I think it's great you feel that way. However...

The stuff you need, you should buy. The stuff that wears out or breaks, you should replace. It then gets dicey with regard to stuff that doesn't work as well as something else. An example:

I HATE raised panel Craftsman ratchets. I hate the feel, I hate the weight, I hate the ratcheting mechanism feel, I hate the feel of a socket going on the square drive. I'm not even sure how far back that goes, but it had to have been my early teens or before. So my point is that I should get something I care to use. And so should you.

Now go back and look at the Facom pliers I posted. Comparing each of the 3 pair of that set I own to equivalent Craftsman models that were more affordable, the handles feel better on the Facom and allow better grip. The jaws have maintained better bite and the hinge mechanism is just a bit smoother. I literally cringe when I look at my old Craftsman "professional" needle nose set because my Facom pair just plain feel better. And, the idea of "lifetime" with regard to those is they work, but they don't really have any bite anymore.

Don't shortchange yourself by even considering brand. Look at the features. As you use your hands and rest of your body and when you're twice as old as you are now, you'll better appreciate features you didn't think about before. And for all I know, the Knipex stuff puts the Facom stuff I have to shame. :dunno:

And "lifetime" tools don't exist when it comes to sharp edges that get used regularly. My pliers that I hate using have a lifetime warranty and I don't care. I'd rather pick up a nice new pair that bite instead of trudging through a Sears store that depresses me and one day will not exist.

Sorry, rant over.


@ durallymax: I do understand what you're saying and there is a lot of truth in it, but I'm not willing to write America off because of it. I support American manufacturers because I want to see us maintain what little manufacturing base we have left. Without getting political, we probably agree on more things than you probably think, but if there is an American product that suits my needs, I'm giving it first look. Sure I occasionally buy a Taiwan or China made tool and I don't feel bad about it, but I'm not going to even attempt to take a position that they are anywhere near the level of quality as the Proto tools that make up 70% of the tools I own. Most German tools are great quality, but I still believe most American tools are as well.
Well, American automakers had to take a ****** beating and they've only gotten better. As overseas produced tool items get better, so will U.S. produced goods. Hopefully that sort of thing improves product from Channellock and others. I related to the "old mechanisms that haven't been changed in decades" post earlier in the thread.
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
Durallymax,

You are fighting an uphill battle over here on GJ. If you do not go on the premise that made in the USA is always best. The COO guys jump all over you. I believe in buying the best tool or item for the job. I just thing paying my hard earn money for a second tier tool, when I can get something that is better for slightly more base on COO is kind of silly. Just look at the type of responses you got on you post.
 

durallymax

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2011
Messages
918
Durallymax,

You are fighting an uphill battle over here on GJ. If you do not go on the premise that made in the USA is always best. The COO guys jump all over you. I believe in buying the best tool or item for the job. I just thing paying my hard earn money for a second tier tool, when I can get something that is better for slightly more base on COO is kind of silly. Just look at the type of responses you got on you post.

I noticed it was more about COO than the best tool. More about supporting fellow Americans, versus buying what does the job best. Not many responses said anything about US being better, just that they can be okay and we should support Americans. I think they get too many handouts, I am not giving them money for something I do not feel does the job for me. With that said though, over half of my box is probably still US made.

To each their own.
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
It is always COO on here, if not COO it is sears is the devil for what they did to craftsman. That craftsman was the holier then thou, and it is a sin that they are not being Asian made for 1/2 their stuff.
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,564
Location
nd
Hi ya'll! So I am building my tool collection (i'm 17 ;)) and I need some input. It seems like sockets, different qualities but the same style; ratchets, a bit more variety but still all similar; combination wrenches, same story. But when you get to pliers there is a massive selection that each have a very specific use. I do not know where to start. What do ya'll think.
I'm not looking to have every tool by the age of twenty or whatever, all I want is to start building a set that will last a lifetime (made in the US of A) and will continue to slowly grow (as money permits) through out a lifetime.
So I guess my question is what brands and what styles of pliers do you find yourselves reaching for the most. Perhaps the top five. Thanks in advance for any input you can give.
Thanks a mill.:D

I noticed it was more about COO than the best tool. More about supporting fellow Americans, versus buying what does the job best. Not many responses said anything about US being better, just that they can be okay and we should support Americans. I think they get too many handouts, I am not giving them money for something I do not feel does the job for me. With that said though, over half of my box is probably still US made.

To each their own.


i hate to argue with people that don't read the op's original post. pretty clearly states he is just starting out, wants made in usa and is asking for the top five brands and styles and as money permits (i assume that means he is on a fairly limited budget). his word and not any others.

right or wrong, that excludes the brands that you, shoturtle and others are telling him he needs causing his whole thread to get sidetracked.

so on price and the fact of it not being us made(again his words not mine) he is asking nothing about your choices yet we are all forced to listen to the ranting and raving about how terrible the us choices are when in fact i there some excellent choices available.
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
So I guess my question is what brands and what styles of pliers do you find yourselves reaching for the most. Perhaps the top five. Thanks in advance for any input you can give.
Thanks a mill.:D

This was the question the OP asked, what style members reach for most. Perhaps the top 5.
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,564
Location
nd
It is always COO on here, if not COO it is sears is the devil for what they did to craftsman. That craftsman was the holier then thou, and it is a sin that they are not being Asian made for 1/2 their stuff.

ah yes wrong again. many have suggested craftsman in this thread, including me.

you get so caught up in "your" agenda that you don't even know what you are typing. it is a shame that craftsman is shifting mfg. of more and more of it's items overseas.

it really is hard to understand but from your comment it looks to me like like you think it is a sin they are not making more of their items in asia. kind of shows your true colors.

ps, i am not anti european tools. i have quite a few felo, wera, facom, knipex and irega made items in my collection. if the op would have asked for reccomendations on them. i would have given them but since he did not it wasn't my place to give it.
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
yes because the COO of the craftsman is USA, WF makes them still.

And you need to read the OP's question, it did not say what USA made pliers members reach for most, and what is the top 5 USA made pliers.

You agenda is clear as day.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom